Member Spotlight

Menu matters: what livestock eat is the missing piece for climate action

Photo: G. Smith (CIAT) (source)

As COP31 draws to a close, the newly launched LD4D Feed Baskets Data Hub offers experts a critical tool to share and collect livestock data, enabling better measurement, tracking, and ultimate reduction of livestock emissions.

Knowing what goes into the diets of animals that produce our milk and meat may seem an easy enough project. But in fact, the question of what animals eat is a surprisingly difficult one to answer, with multiple variations and possibilities.  

Around the world, the lack of data collected and available about what animals eat has consequences for calculating accurate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from livestock. And yet, livestock emissions from manure and enteric fermentation account for roughly a one-third of human-caused methane emissions.  

With demand for animal protein set to increase, the new LD4D Feed Baskets Data Hub helps experts share and collect livestock data to better measure, track and ultimately reduce livestock emissions. As negotiators gather for COP31, researchers, funders and governments all have a part to play to ensure that data can inform better decisions to reduce emissions.  

Without [feed baskets] data, we can neither estimate the methane [animals are] producing, which matters for inventories and climate policy development, nor begin to change and improve diets, because we don't know what they were eating in the first place
- Andrew Bisson, Spark Climate Solutions 

Why does the menu matter?

For most farmers, knowing what their animals eat is about productivity. "The reason why farmers, nutrition advisors, feed companies and policy makers want to know what cows eat is really just to make cows healthier, more productive, a better asset for a farmer," says Andrew Bisson, an animal health expert and Interim Director of Spark Climate Solutions’ Livestock Enteric Methane Mitigation Program, who took part in the LD4D Feed Baskets initiative.   

The organization is dedicated to accelerating under-resourced but high-impact climate mitigation solutions. Well-fed animals can mean more productive farms, more nutrient-dense food and stronger rural economies, he explains. And better knowledge about livestock diet data also provides a baseline against which methane emissions can be tracked and measured.  "If it's a black box and you don't know what the animals are eating, you can't really begin to provide nutritional information,” he explains.  

“Without that data, we can neither estimate the methane they're producing, which matters for inventories and climate policy development, nor begin to change and improve diets, because we don't know what they were eating in the first place,” he says. Whether meeting climate targets or understanding carbon credits and payments farmers might receive, “none of that is possible without a baseline,” he notes. “If you don't know what changed, you can't estimate any improvements, so you lose that positive, virtuous feedback loop.” 

Even where good feed data exists, it is rarely shared. Cleaning, documenting and packaging a dataset takes considerable effort, Bisson points out, "and there's no immediate return or benefit for the person holding the data." Researchers also worry they will not be credited when others reuse their work. Until recently, there was not even an obvious place to share it, although that has changed with the launch of the LD4D Feed Baskets Data Hub.   

Data is power

So why is livestock data so hard to gather and share? Ram Dhulipala, Director of CGIAR’s Digital Transformation Accelerator (DTA), who took part in the LD4D Feed Baskets initiative, notes that in smallholder systems especially in the global south, farmers use a lot of crop stubble from their farms as feed and fodder for their cattle.  

Measuring data about what crops were sown, the yield, the price, especially when part of informal networks, is in itself a huge data collection and data compilation challenge, he says. “Here you are speaking about whatever is left over after the farmer has harvested. That is even more difficult data to collect. Data collection in smallholder farming systems, especially related to feed availability and the feed farmers use, is a huge data collection and data compilation problem.”  

Farmers may also use informal markets and networks to source feed.  

Responsibility is scattered, too. "When it comes to feed, it's no one's business,” he notes. Data collection is funded project by project, with fragmentation across the sector and no hard and fast requirements to collect, store and share livestock feed data. That in turn has implications for decision making at policy level. Without data specific to breeds and feeds, policymakers fall back on generic emission factors, with implications for tracking emissions.  

Building the investment case

Developed through LD4D by partners including Cornell University, the World Bank, ILRI, FAO, the University of Edinburgh and Wageningen University, this is the gap the Feed Baskets Data Hub sets out to close. It provides a framework for sharing and collecting existing data, as well as guidance on collecting good primary data, with sharing in mind from the start.   

With credible data, countries can set defensible climate targets and attract finance, says Bisson. "On the policy front, you can set smart climate targets that are defensible, and you can source climate finance at the national level to reduce your emissions. If you have solid data on where you are, and a system that shows your emissions coming down as you make incremental improvements, that's very attractive to institutional investors.”  

Investors will get a degree of certainty from quality baseline data and monitoring systems. “Without those systems and without data, it's a shot in the dark,” he adds. That is a lost investment opportunity. “Data is power, and it's powerful in informing future decisions. It seems intuitively clear that quality data management systems are a really important precursor for countries to meet this big opportunity to grow their livestock sectors, and to grow them sustainably. That's going to need data.” 

At the same time, demand for animal protein is rising in many regions, and artificial intelligence (AI) promises new tools for farmers and policymakers. But AI can only accelerate insights if there is enough data to draw from. As Dhulipala explains: “Data scientists spend around 60% of their time finding and curating data. So, the AI-in-agriculture community really needs to solve its data discovery and data exchange problem.”  

Get involved

  • Explore the prototype: Visit feedbaskets.livestockdata.org to review the feed baskets data guide, examine the proposed common schema, and browse the current registry. 

  • Contribute your data: The Hub's success depends on community participation. We encourage you to submit details about your open-access datasets and metadata to help test and refine the system. 

  • Share your feedback: As we move from prototype to practice, your insights on what works and what needs improvement are vital. Get in touch: ld4d@ed.ac.uk 

Help us co-create the future of feed data!